Moldinspector.com Online Since 1999
 
Do-It-Yourself Blog for Mold Health &Mold Inspection, Testing, Removal, & Prevention, Plus Air Duct Cleaning & Building Decontamination by EnviroFry for Homes, Workplaces, & Commercial Buildings Nationwide USA, Canada, Europe, Middle East, Asia, Australia/N.Z., South America, and Worldwide!
 
 
Mold Expert Consultant  What Is Mold?  Mold Health  Mold News Mold Legal Liability Mold Inspection 
 Mold Inspector Directory  Mold Lab Analysis Mold Removal  Mold Products  Air Conditioning Mold  Workplace Mold  
 Mold Prevention  Mold Real Estate Problems  Mold Inspection Clause  Top 10 Mold Mistakes 
10 Steps To Find Hidden Mold 
 
10 Mold Inspection Steps 10 Steps Prevent Mold Legal Problems  Mold Q & A  Vehicle Detoxification  Mold Inspector Training
 
 
Contact Mold Expert Phillip Fry phil@moldinspector.com  Phone Phillip Toll-Free 1-866-300-1616 or 1-810-639-0523
or cell phone 1-480-310-7970      
Visit the Site Map at the bottom of this page.

For mold inspection, building mold inspection, mold inspector directory, mold remediation, and mold prevention for your real estate property anywhere in USA, Canada, Asia, Europe, or worldwide, please contact mold consultants Phillip Fry and Divine Fry by email phil@moldinspector.com or by phone Phillip Toll-Free 1-866-300-1616 USA and Canada or Phillip's cell phone 1-480-310-7970

Read about the Fraudulent Mold Health Study Used by Insurance Companies, Landlords, and Employers
to Deny Mold Is a Health Risk
 

Court of Opinion: Amid Suits Over Mold, Experts Wear Two Hats Authors of Science Paper Often Cited by Defense Also Help in Litigation
 

WALL STREET JOURNAL, Jan. 9, 2007, page A 1 by David Armstrong 

 
Soon after moving into a New York City apartment, Colin and Pamela Fraser say, they began to suffer headaches, rashes, respiratory infections and fatigue. They attributed it to mold.

But their lawsuit against the cooperative that owns the building hit a roadblock when the court wouldn't let their medical expert testify that mold caused their problems. This is "unsupported by the scientific literature," the state trial judge said.

She relied in part on a position paper from the American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, or ACOEM. Citing a substance some molds produce called mycotoxins, the paper said "scientific evidence does not support the proposition that human health has been adversely affected by inhaled mycotoxins in the home, school, or office environment."

The paper has become a key defense tool wielded by builders, landlords and insurers in litigation. It has also been used to assuage fears of parents following discovery of mold in schools. One point that rarely emerges in these cases: The paper was written by people who regularly are paid experts for the defense side in mold litigation.

The ACOEM doesn't disclose this, nor did its paper. The professional society's president, Tee Guidotti, says no disclosure is needed because the paper represents the consensus of its membership and is a statement from the society, not the individual authors.

The dual roles show how conflicts of interest can color debate on emerging health issues and influence litigation related to it. Mold has been a contentious matter since a Texas jury in 2001 awarded $32.1 million to a family whose home was mold-infested. That award, later reduced, and a couple of mold suits filed by famous people like Ed McMahon and Erin Brockovich helped trigger a surge in mold litigation. Insurers and builders worried it would become a liability disaster for them on the scale of asbestos.

The number of suits hasn't been as big as anticipated. One reason appears to be the insurers' success in getting many states to exclude mold coverage from homeowner's-insurance policies. But also helping turn the tide, lawyers and doctors say, is the ACOEM report. Building groups and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce have cited it to rebut the notion that mold in the home can be toxic.
James Craner, a Nevada doctor who has testified for scores of people who claimed ill effects from mold, says the paper "has been used in every single mold case. The lawyer asks, 'Isn't it true the American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine concluded that there is no scientific evidence that mold causes any serious health effects?'"

The result, Dr. Craner maintains, is that "a lot people with legitimate environmental health problems are losing their homes and their jobs because of legal decisions based on this so-called 'evidence-based' statement."

Dr. Craner says a majority of his work is on the plaintiff side and he is paid when he testifies, but he says he currently is an expert for the defense in a case where he concluded the plaintiffs' health issues weren't related to mold.

Two other medical societies have also published statements on mold written, in part, by legal-defense experts. The societies didn't disclose this when they released the papers, although one later published a correction saying two authors served as expert witnesses in mold litigation.

Mold reproduces through tiny spores. These can float into homes through windows and vent systems or be carried in on clothes or shoes. Indoors, mold grows when moisture is present.

There's debate about how much this matters. Plaintiffs attribute ills ranging from asthma to cognitive problems to inhalation of mold. The Institute of Medicine, a largely federally funded nonprofit, reviewed the research in 2004 and said "studies have demonstrated adverse effects -- including immunotoxic, neurologic, respiratory and dermal responses -- after exposure to specific toxins, bacteria, molds or their products." But it added that the dose required to cause adverse health effects hasn't been determined. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, for its part, says on its Web site that mold can cause wheezing and eye or skin irritation, but a link to more serious conditions "has not been proven."

'Highly Unlikely'

The ACOEM paper goes further. It says not only is there no evidence indoor mold causes serious health effects, but even if mold produced toxic substances, it's "highly unlikely at best" that anyone could inhale enough to cause a problem. The paper reaches this conclusion by extrapolating from animal studies in which rodents' throats were injected with molds.

The paper's authors say their conclusions are validated by the Institute of Medicine's paper. But the author of the Institute paper's mold toxicity chapter, Harriett Ammann, disagrees, and criticizes the ACOEM paper's
methodology: "They took hypothetical exposure and hypothetical toxicity and jumped to the conclusion there is nothing there."

Dr. Ammann, a recently retired toxicologist for Washington state's health department, recently helped the plaintiff side in a mold case. She says this was the only time she has done so for pay. In the Fraser lawsuit in New York, after the judge barred testimony that mold caused health problems, Dr.
Ammann, on her own and without pay, provided an affidavit filed with the appellate court saying the judge misinterpreted the research.

The ACOEM, a society of more than 5,000 specialists who investigate indoor health hazards and treat patients with related illnesses, first moved to develop a position paper on mold in early 2002. Dean Grove, then the medical society's president, asked the head of its council on scientific affairs, Yale medical professor Jonathan Borak, to set the process in motion.

He turned to a retired deputy director of the National Institute
for Occupational Safety and Health -- part of the CDC -- to spearhead the project. Dr. Borak says he wanted someone with "no established background record of litigation related to mold."

For the Defense
The person he chose, Bryan Hardin, says he hadn't worked on any mold lawsuit at that point, though he was a consultant on other matters for GlobalTox Inc., a firm that regularly worked for the defense in mold cases. And Dr.
Hardin says he consulted for the defense in a mold case while he was helping write the ACOEM paper.

In a Feb. 27, 2002, email, Dr. Borak told Dr. Hardin: "That position paper would be prepared by you and your GlobalTox colleagues." Dr. Borak says he believes he didn't know at the time that GlobalTox did mold defense work.

A GlobalTox colleague who aided Dr. Hardin was Bruce Kelman, now president of the firm, which recently changed its name to Veritox Inc. Drs. Kelman and Hardin, now principals at the firm and entitled to a share of its profits, were two of the ACOEM paper's three authors. They are paid $375 to $500 an hour for work on mold cases, court records say.

EXPERT WITNESSES

 The Situation: Mold defendants rely on medical-society position papers that reject a link to serious ills, but papers were written by scientists who often work for defense side in mold cases.

The Debate: Whether courts get accurate or skewed view of possible health effects of indoor mold.

What's at Stake: Outcome of widespread litigation over mold.

The paper's third author was Andrew Saxon, then chief of clinical immunology and allergy at the medical school of the University of California, Los Angeles. He, too, has served as a defense expert in numerous mold suits. Dr.
Saxon says he is paid $510 an hour for his help. If called to testify in court, his rate rises to $720 an hour, according to a deposition he gave.

Until he retired from UCLA in September, money he earned as a legal-defense expert was paid to the university, and he says UCLA then gave him a little less than half of it. Dr. Saxon estimates he generates $250,000 to $500,000 a year from expert defense work, which includes non-mold cases.

The ACOEM knew about mold defense work by the authors of its paper. Dr.
Hardin informed the society in a Sept. 23, 2002, document under his letterhead. Labeled "confidential" and "share only with the ACOEM board of directors," it told of his work as a defense expert on one mold case.

The letter said the other two authors, Drs. Saxon and Kelman, "have been retained by both the defense and plaintiff bar in litigation relating to indoor mold." Both say they work mostly for the defense in mold cases.

Internal ACOEM documents indicate that as the paper was being written in August 2002, there was concern within the society that the paper was too friendly to defense interests. Its authors were asked to modify the first draft's tone "because of the concern about possible misinterpretation of 'buzz words' and phrases such as 'belief system,' 'adherents may claim,'
'supposed hypersensitivity,' and 'alleged disorder,'" according to a June
2002 email to Dr. Hardin from the society's communications director. (The email was obtained by a plaintiff's attorney in a mold case, Karen Kahn.)

Dr. Borak, the head of the society's council on scientific affairs, suggested sending a draft for review to one particular mold authority, Michael Hodgson, director of the occupational safety and health program at the U.S. Veterans Health Administration. Dr. Hardin objected. He said it would be "inappropriate to add ad hoc reviewers who are highly visible advocates for a point of view the draft position paper analyzes and finds lacking." The draft ultimately wasn't sent.

'A Defense Argument'
In September 2002, Dr. Borak emailed colleagues that "I am having quite a challenge in finding an acceptable path for the proposed position paper on mold." He said several reviewers "find the current version, much revised, to still be a defense argument."

The society released a paper two months later, and its authors, as well as ACOEM officials, say it accurately reflects the science on indoor mold exposure. The authors' "views, if prejudicial, were removed," Dr. Borak says. "It went through a dramatic change of top-heavy peer reviews." He says objections come mainly from "activist litigants" who find it "annoying."

Drs. Hardin and Kelman say the paper has been controversial because it challenged "a belief system" that mold can be toxic indoors. "A belief system is built up and there is anger when the science doesn't support that belief system," Dr. Kelman says.

The Manhattan Institute, a conservative think tank, paid Veritox $40,000 to prepare a lay version of the paper. That version said "the notion that 'toxic mold' is an insidious, secret 'killer,' as so many media reports and trial lawyers would claim, is 'junk science' unsupported by actual scientific study." Its authors were the three writers of the longer paper plus a fourth, who also is a principal at Veritox.

Lawyers defending mold suits also cite a position paper from the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology. This paper says it concurs with the ACOEM that it is highly unlikely enough mycotoxins could be inhaled to lead to toxic health effects.
Among the academy paper's five authors is Dr. Saxon. Another, Abba Terr, a San Francisco immunologist, has worked as a defense expert in mold cases.
The academy published the paper in its Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology last February, not citing the mold-defense work of either man.
The publication later ran a correction disclosing their litigation work.

The academy's president says officials were aware Dr. Saxon was an expert witness. "We should have published their [disclosure] statements with the paper," says the official, Thomas Platts-Mills. He says the lapse resulted from a variety of factors, including confusion about whose responsibility the disclosure was.

Unhappy Author
A third author of the academy's paper, Jay Portnoy, chief of allergy, asthma and immunology at the Children's Mercy Hospital in Kansas City, Mo., says he "felt that there was an agenda" -- the effort "seemed very biased toward denying the possibility of there being harmful effects from mold on human health." He says he considered removing his name from the paper, but it was published before he could decide.

Dr. Portnoy says a section he contributed was rewritten by Dr. Saxon to be "a lot more negative." He says the paper wrongly says mold isn't proven to cause allergic rhinitis, with symptoms like wheezing, sore throat and sneezing. Dr. Saxon denies the authors had a bias but says they applied a high standard for proving mold causes a particular effect. He says he didn't skew the content of Dr. Portnoy's section but rewrote it because it was "too diffuse." Dr. Terr in San Francisco didn't return a call seeking comment.

In New York, the Frasers are appealing the refusal of the trial judge, state Supreme Court Justice Shirley Werner Kornreich, to let their expert testify that indoor mold caused their health complaints. The Frasers had moved into the East Side Manhattan apartment in 1996. Their 2002 suit said they repeatedly complained to the co-op's board of dampness and leaks as their health deteriorated.

Their appeal attacks the credibility of mold position papers drafted by scientists who work for defendants. "What you have here is defense experts authoring papers under an official guise," says their attorney, Elizabeth Eilender. Justice Kornreich declined to comment.

Write to David Armstrong at
david.armstrong@wsj.com

 

Be trained and certified as a Certified Mold Inspector, Certified Mold Remediator, and/or Certified Environmental Hygienist
 
Solve Your Home Mold Problems for $99 anywhere in the world with the UNLIMITED (60 days) expert email guidance, direction, and assistance of Phillip Fry, Certified Mold Inspector, Certified Environmental Inspector, Certified Mold Remediator, and Certified Environmental Hygienist!
 

Mold Library Combination
Read the 5 mold advice ebooks in the Mold Library Combination, for a combined discount price of only $49.00 [$75.00 if bought separately]. Combo package includes: (a) Do-It-Best-Yourself Mold Prevention, Inspection, Testing, and Remediation, $15; (b) Mold Health Guide, $15; (c) Mold Legal Guide, $15; (d) Mold Home Remedy Recipes, $15; and (e) Mold Monsters, $15.  All helpful ebooks are delivered to your designated email address by email attachments only within 12-24 hours of your order. Order Now!
 
Learn the 10 steps for safe and effective mold remediation.

Western USA Mold Inspection Websites
 
Arizona Mold Inspection
 
Las Vegas Mold Inspection
 
Los Angeles Mold Inspection
 
Mesa Mold Inspection
 
Orange County Mold
 
Palm Springs Mold Inspection
 
Phoenix Mold Inspection
 
Sacramento Mold Inspection
 
San Diego Mold Inspection
 
San Francisco Mold Inspection
 
San Jose Mold Inspection
 
Santa Barbara Mold Inspection
 
Scottsdale Mold Inspection
 
Tucson Mold Inspector
 
Victorville Mold Inspection
 
Certified Environmental Hygienists  ►Ozone Kills Mold  ►Ozone Odor Control  ►Carpet Deodorizer  ►Mold Expert Consultants
 
  
 

[Home] [Masonry-Mold] [Katrina-Mold-Study] [Fraudulent-Mold-Health-Study] [Apartment-Toxic-Mold] [Ozone-Air-Purifiers] [Mold-Odor-Asthma] [Mold-Mushroom-Photo] [Mold-Sinus-Problems] [Dampness-Mold-Health] [Environmental-Mold-Home-Study] [Chronic-Sinusitis-Mold-Problem] [Alzheimer's & Mold] [Mold-Death] [Asthma & Mold] [Blood Testing] [Mold Headache] [Mold & Landscaping] [Household-Mold-Dangers] [Top-100-Mold-Health-Signs-&-Symptoms] [Mold-Health-Issues] [Scope-Of-Mold-Problem] [Mold Scientist] [Skin Diseases] [Stachybotrys Information] [Mold-Desert] [Cold-or-Allergies] [Mold-Health-Effects] [Mold-Health-Questions] [Tsunami-Deadly-Fungal-Infection] [Mold-Birth-Defects] [Ten-Health-Symptoms] [Seasonal-Allergies] [Mold-Respiratory-Hazards] [Mold-Pregnancy] [Sinusitis-Mold-Growth] [Lung-Cancer-Mold] [Asthma-Mold] [Pet-Mold-Problem] [German-Mold-Research] [Fungal-Eye-Infection] [Mold-Causes-Depression] [Asthma-Cats-Alternia-Mold] [Fungal-Research] [Neuropsychological-Mold-Link] [Tornado Mold] [Tropical Mold Infections] [Sink Mold Sickness] [Soda Pop from Aspergillus] [Aspergillosis Misdiagnosed as TB] [Fungal Infection Mimics Cancer]
 

Site Map

Air Conditioning Mold
Antifungal Spray
Antimicrobial Coating
Apartment Mold
Asthma Home Remedies
Asthma and Mold
Attic Mold
Basement Toxic Black Mold
Bathroom Toxic Black Mold
Biblical Mold Inspectors
Bleach Ineffective Mold
Black Mold
Black Mold Picture
Black Mold Remover
Black Mold Symptom
Brain Mold
Black Mold Home
Build Mold-Safe Home
Car/Van/Truck Mold
Carpeting Mold
Ceiling Mold
Certified Mold Inspector
Certified Mold Remediator
Cleaning Mold
Closet Mold
Concrete Floor Mold
Condominium Mold Problem
Construction Mold
Co-Operative Apartment Mold
Crawl Space Mold
Dangerous Molds
Demolition Moldy Home
Do-It-Yourself Mold Book

Eliminate Mold

Employer Mold Liability
Employer Mold Problem
Environmental College
Environmental Detective
Environmental Education
Environmental Training
EPA Mold Recommendations

Find Mold
Fire & Mold


Flooding
Flood & Mold
Flood Prevention Tips
Flood Water Damage Prevention
Floor Mold
Fungicide
Garage Mold
Gutter Mold
Health Effects of Mold
Herbal Remedies
Hidden Mold

High Blood Pressure
Home Builder Mold
Home Construction Mold

Home Mold Detection
Home Mold Removal Remedy
Home Remedy for Killing Mold
Home Selling and Mold
Home Buying and Mold
House Mold
House Mold Inspection
House Mold Removal Remedy
Household Mold
How To Get Rid of Mold
How To Kill Mold

Humidifier Mold Problem
Hurricane & Mold
Hurricane Katrina Mold Problems
Hypertension
Indoor Plant Mold
Insurance Claim Mold
Kill Mold in Home
Killing Mold
Kitchen Mold
Landlord Mold Liability
Lift Tape Mold Sampling
Manufactured Home
Mobile Home Mold Problem
Mold

Mold & Health
Mold & Mildew
Mold & Mildew Removal
Mold Abatement

Mold Advice
Mold Allergy

Mold Allergy Symptom
Mold Analysis
Mold Books
Mold Certification
Mold Cleaner
Mold Cleaning
Mold Cleanup
Mold Consultant
Mold Contractor
Mold Count
Mold Cross-Contamination
Mold Depression
Mold Detection
Mold Doctor
Mold Education
Mold Expert
Mold Health Symptoms
Mold Home Remedy Recipes
Mold Illnesses
Mold in Basement
Mold in Home
Mold in House
Mold in Water Testing
Mold Information

Mold Inspection
Mold Inspector
Mold Investigation
Mold Killer
Mold Law

Mold Legal Liability
Mold Medical Problems
Mold Mitigation
Mold Monsters book
Mold News
Mold Prevention
Mold Prevention Consultant
Mold Problem
Mold Remediation

Mold Remediation Protocol
Mold Remediator
Mold Removal
Mold Remover

Mold Resistant Paint
Mold Resistant Paint Tips
Mold Class
Mold School

Mold Seminar
Mold Specialist
Mold Species
Mold Species Information
Mold Species Identification 
Mold Spore
Mold Symptom
Mold Test
Mold Testing
Mold Test Kits
Mold Training
Mold Treatment
New Home Mold
Office Mold
OSB and Mold
Ozone Blasting
Ozone Generator
Ozone Kills Mold
Pet Health and Mold
Plumbing Leak Mold
Pregnancy & Toxic Black Mold
Real Estate and Mold
Removing Mold
Retail Store Mold
School Mold
Scotch
® Tape Mold Test
Siding Mold
Sinus Infection
Slime Mold
Stop Mold Growth
Symptoms of Black Mold
Symptoms of Toxic Mold
Testing Mold
Tornado & Mold
Toxic Black Mold
Toxic Mold
Toxic Mold Home
Treat Toxic Black Mold
Truck Mold
Tsunami & Mold
Tsunami Deadly Mold
Type of Mold

Typhoon & Mold
Vehicle Mold
Wall Mold
Wallpaper Mold
Window Mold
Workplace Mold

How To Order Mold and Enviro Products by Phone and Email
PHONE ORDER: You can place your order by phoning mold consultant Phillip Fry Toll-Free 866-300-1616
or Phillip's cell phone 480-310-7970 USA/Canada, 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern Time, Monday through Saturday.
EMAIL ORDER:  You can also email your order by printing, completing, and emailing the Email Order Form.

Top Ten Mold Mistakes  Mold Inspection Steps  Mold Remediation Steps  Hire Mold Expert  Home Repairs
 Mold TrainingTop 100 Mold Health Problems Real Estate Mold Problems Legal Liability for Mold FREE Mold Advice
  Industrial Hygienist Training Industrial Hygienist Directory Ozone Kills Mold  Mold Fogging Machine  DIY Mold
 
 Mold Consultant  Household Mold Removal  Tim-Bor Workplace Mold  Business Mold 
Building Decontamination 
 Company Mold  Air Con Mold  Prevent Mold Indoor Pollution Phoenix Mold Inspection 
Do It Yourself Mold Removal 

 What Is Mold?PollutionBusters  Mold Inspector Directory Mold Fogger  
Mold Test Dallas Texas 
Mold Inspection Dallas Texas  Houston Toxic Mold Testing House Mold Testing Texas Mold Inspection  Mold Marines 
Ozone Odor Remover  Hurricane Mold Remediation Victorville Mold Inspection Palm Springs Mold Inspection
Santa Barbara Mold Inspection
  Mold Advice Hotline Building Maintenance Training  DIY Mold Removal  
 

Use high ozone blasting to kill mold, viruses, bacteria, and odors .

Traducción española por Inspector del Molde Website   Site Web de Inspetor de Molde de Tradução Português
La Traduction française pour l'Inspecteur de Moisissure le Site Internet  Besuchen Sie deutsche Übersetzung des Form-Inspektors Website
Посетите российский перевод Инспектора Почвы вебсайт

Copyright 2015 Environmental Hygienists Association   All Rights Reserved  Last Updated: Dec. 1, 2015
For mold inspection, mold remediation, and mold prevention for your real estate property anywhere in the world, please contact
mold consultants Phillip Fry and Divine Fry  email phil@moldinspector.com or call Phillip Toll-Free 1-866-300-1616 or cell phone 1-480-310-7970